Politics in the real world is messy. It tends to be about compromises – with each other, with our past failures, with our current limitations.
This kind of politics is important. But the mess sometimes limits our ability to think clearly about what we’re doing.
In physics, when you have a problem with too many “messy” variables, you use simplifying assumptions – famously including assuming that cows are perfectly spherical when estimating their mass. This might seem silly, but it has a profound effect – by using these simplifying assumptions, physicists can often get a much clearer head around the most important, central facets of what they are working with.
I want to do the same thing with constitutional engineering. Rather than asking questions like “what laws could we reasonably pass today” or “how do we find compromises between these different party preferences”, I want to simplify the problem – not because my simplified answer is perfect, but because I think it reveals a foundation upon which we can build, and gives us direction for what our political systems should be evolving towards over time.
So let’s talk about the USA, but simplified into a bunch of spherical cows.
Founding Principles
From a spherical-cow perspective, I believe a supermajority of Americans would agree that the following principles capture the “spirit of America” that matters to them, and that anyone who disagreed on any of these should not be an American citizen.
- The Principle of Freedom. The government should not limit a citizen’s actions except where those actions would harm others.
- The Principle of Benefit. Every citizen should be better off with the government existing than they would be in its absence.
- The Principle of Democracy. The government should focus its resources and effort on problems proportionally based on how much those problems matter to each citizen.
- The Principle of Inclusion. Any individual who believes in these principles, is willing to follow the laws of the nation, and is able to contribute (on net, over their life as a citizen) more back to the country than they it costs to support them as a citizen, should have the option to become a citizen.
Arguably the most debate from real-world Americans would be on the Principle of Inclusion; real-world Americans might demand certain additional constraints like particular racial, religious, or capitalistic profiles. But I would argue that this (for most, though not all) actually motivated by fear of violations of the Principles of Freedom, Benefit, or Democracy if those ‘outsiders’ were given citizenship. In spherical-cow-land, where we presume we could absolutely give an ironclad promise that those Principles will never be violated, and that any would-be citizen whose inclusion would diminish the principles will not be accepted, I believe that (again, not all, but a supermajority) Americans would then agree with the Principle of Inclusion as well.
Game-Theoretic Necessities
The above four principles are the key choices that shape the kind of society that we want to make; but there are many requirements which then fall out of these principles in combination with game theory, system design, and other best practices.
- The Legibility Requirement. Citizens will not obey or respect enforcement of rules they were unaware of. Thus, no individual should be held accountable for a violation of a rule they could not reasonably have known or understood in advance of their violation.
- The Heterogeneity Requirement. The Principles of Freedom and Inclusion imply a highly diverse populous. Since some individuals who satisfy the requirements for citizenship may have mutually incompatible preferences, the country must support different “districts” which operate in highly diverse ways (though never in violation of the Principles.)
- The Tolerance Limit. The Principle of Inclusion naturally has limits; one critical one is that the government must aggressively, permanently, and without compromise banish, exclude, or otherwise remove any would-be citizens who take even a single action whose primary purpose is the suffering of even a single other citizens.
- The Positivity Requirement. The government may only be permitted to influence other citizens by creating positive incentives, such that (by the Principle of Benefit), taking the incentivized option leaves the citizen better off than they would have been if the government had not existed. The only exception to this is removing individuals outside of the Tolerance Limit.
- The Ambiguity Requirement. Since habits are built easily and it’s generally impossible to tell at a glance whether an individual is a citizen or not, any action which would be against the law if the victim were a citizen, must be prevented by any in-the-moment law enforcement on the assumption that the victim is in fact a citizen.
Only-Somewhat-United States
An obvious takeaway of the Heterogeneity Requirement is that the nation must separate into “districts”, which I’ll call States for simplicity, with the Federal Government being the entity that oversees the collective States. These States can and should have wildly different ways of operating, provided that they honor the following rights of all citizens:
- Exit Rights. No State may prevent any citizen who desires to leave the State from doing so.
- Further, the Federal Government should endeavor to make it as inexpensive/simple a decision as possible for an individual to leave their State (subject to common-sense limits for individuals who might exploit such services.)
- Education Rights. No State may prevent any citizen from learning about the other States, including what the others think of their State.
- Further, the Federal Government should endeavor to provide standardized resources to all States making this education as seamless and effective as possible.
- Further, the Federal Government must directly reach any children it believes the State is insufficiently educating (with the standard for ‘sufficiency’ being that, as the child turns of age, they are able to make a truly informed decision about whether to stay in their State or move to another), even if this act appears to impose on the freedom and rights of the State or the child’s caretakers.
- Principle Rights. The State must yield to the Federal Government in any cases where the Federal Government deems the actions of the States to violate the Founding Principles, the Game Theoretic Requirements, or these rights.
My Ideal State
While I don’t expect to have the opportunity to implement this vision directly, if I did, I would consider it of the utmost importance to only implement the sections above. Those sections are the result of foundational assumptions and the logic of cooperation, NOT my personal preferences or opinion.
Everything from here on, though, IS my personal preference. Specifically, the ways my ideal State would operate, even if other States might operate differently.
Corporations Don’t Exist, People Do
People respond to incentives. If nobody is incentivized to prevent an outcome, they will not generally fight to prevent it.
The “corporate veil” is a legal concept that generally protects business leaders from personal liability if their company does something bad. The core problem with this is that it breaks the incentives. If the only entity held liable is “the company”, then nobody is being held liable, because “the company” is not in fact a person and cannot respond to incentives.
If a major corporation is found to be polluting a small town’s drinking water; chronically addicting children to dangerous content; manipulating democracy; or even simply lying to its customers…someone should be held responsible.
When you punish companies, you can only extract monetary assets from them, since that’s all the company really has. But this money often fails to amount to even a slap on the wrist for the people responsible.
I do believe that corporations and individuals should have separate finances. But I believe that corporations can not break the law; only people can do that. So when a law is broken, I believe that the people who broke it should be held responsible.
Specifically, in my Ideal State, corporations are solely a mechanism to distribute wealth, not liability.
When an individual wishes to pursue a venture alone, they simply do so. There is no value in legally “incorporating” if they will also be pursuing this initiative solo.
When multiple individuals wish to pursue a joint venture, they create a Company. A “Company” is effectively a co-owned bank account, where each “Owner” controls a portion of the existing funds proportional to the number of “Shares” that Owner possesses.
As a simple example, Anna may own 40 Shares of a Company, while Brandon owns the remaining 10 Shares. If the Company holds $100, then Anna may allocate the use of up to $80, while Brandon can allocate the use of up to $20, and any use of the full $100 naturally requires both to authorize their respective pieces.
The purpose of creating a Company is to direct profits directly to the Company – it’s purely infrastructure to facilitate automated distribution of profits to Shareholders. There is no separate pile of money that belongs to “the company alone” – at all times, each dollar belongs to a specific owner who makes the decision whether to continue to invest it in growth or to withdraw it.
(Strictly speaking, a Company isn’t even one bank account – it’s N bank accounts, where N is the number of Shareholders. The money is divided up immediately as the profits come in – so if Anna blows her $80 on a steak dinner, she does not have any claim on Brandon’s $20, but does still receive 80% of any new profits that come in.) Profits always are distributed across all Shareholders proportional to their ownership; if you wanted profits to only flow to you, based on work you feel only you did, then your project isn’t actually part of the same Company.
A Company is created via registering a Charter. The purpose of a Charter is solely to lay out the criteria by which Shares are managed or allocated. This criteria can in principle be anything, but in practice most commonly looks something like:
Every [___] months, all Shareholders will vote on a new distribution of Shares, with one Share equal to one vote. First, each Owner is invited to submit a proposed distribution, and each Owner may allocate any number of their votes to any such distribution with the intention of rejecting such a distribution. The five distributions with the least votes – therefore the least objectionable distributions – then are put up for the second round of voting, in which each vote is taken as a positive indication in favor of that distribution. The distribution ending the second round with the most votes is then put into effect immediately.
Companies (specifically the bank-account-distribution) are administrated by Administrators, which may themselves be individuals, Companies, or the State itself.
Legal actions cannot involve Companies, only individuals:
- Companies cannot sign legal documents and (for instance) make commitments to serve a customer for years to come; only individual Stakeholders can sign commitments to themselves vote or act in certain ways. The counterparty bears the risk that the Shareholders they extracted a commitment from may see their Shares decreased in the future.
- A mistreated customer may file a suit against a Company, but only as part of the initial filing; in such a filing, the judiciary must first identify the responsible individual within the Company who will be the defendant. Multiple such defendants may be interviewed in the course of this investigation, and even ultimately penalized, but all such defendants are penalized individually.
- A Company cannot sue its Administrator, but the Shareholders of the Company absolutely can sue the Administrator for mishandling its funds; provided that, if the Administrator is a Company, the above restriction applies.
- Companies cannot own Intellectual Property; only individuals can, who then authorize its use by other individuals as appropriate.
Regulations Don’t Exist, Education Does
Broadly speaking, I dislike the government regulating things in the sense of “preventing citizens from doing things unless they meet specific criteria.”
I think the much more effective and morally correct solution is for the government to audit the way producers are building their goods, and to make it stupendously easy for citizens to understand the results of those audits. This might include things like certifications.
Obviously this requires citizens to trust that centralized audit authority, but this is achievable, because the whole point of such an entity is that it would do EVERYTHING out in the open. (Not in the “file a request and we’ll share an opaque file in three months” sense, but in the “we are legitimately building in public and constantly sharing what we are learning” sense.)
I can see arguments against this strictly for kids or for goods so destructive (like nuclear weapons) that even a single individual misusing the good could cause irreparable damage. Outside these criteria, the only penalty for “violating” a “regulation” should be that the public is told clearly about what you’re doing and permitted to make their own decision on the tradeoffs.
Privacy Is A Choice, To A Point
The State follows Estonia’s once-only principle, where it maintains a centralized database of relevant information about its citizens. When a citizen identifies themselves to the State, the State can – and indeed, must look up any relevant information from the database, rather than forcing the citizen to provide it a second (or third, or nth time.)
Each citizen has access to their own database records and can correct any inaccurate information.
Citizens can submit their privacy preferences to the State regarding what sorts of information they are ok having be shared with what entities under what circumstances. Then, if e.g. a business sees your name/license-plate/credit-card/other individual identifier, they submit a request to the State for any other relevant information they need about you, and the State responds or doesn’t based on your preferences.
It is illegal for any business to deny services outright due to an individual’s privacy settings preventing their information from being sued, though it’s perfectly acceptable for the services to be customized based on information made available (if such information is in fact made available), and even for the price to change (though it must change transparently.)
It is illegal for any business to store any information which is also stored in the State database, except for a single alphanumeric identifier used to match a business’ record to the corresponding State database record (which is provided if the business initially did a lookup based on something else like a name or license plate.)
Prices Are Clear
It is illegal to bundle multiple charges for a single item or service. E.g. paying $12.99 for dinner, but also $1.37 in taxes, and also $2.04 in a mandatory service fee, is UNACCEPTABLE; the dinner must simply be listed at the final cost of $16.40.
Additional fees for additional services are acceptable. So if the service fee was optional (perhaps dictating whether you got ‘premium service’ or not), or if you’re paying e.g. a delivery fee for the food to be driven to you, those extra fees are allowed, though a full accounting of all relevant fees and precisely what they are for is required before any purchase can be complete.
What this basically means is that any purchaser always knows exactly what their money is being used for, and always has the option to NOT pay a fee and still complete a purchase (minus whatever add-on the fee granted them).
Also, tipping is not outlawed, but is explicitly excluded from any calculations of whether someone is making a living wage, and it does not receive any special tax treatment compared to normal income.
While it’s not a law, I would hope that the norm in my State would be that you tip only if you truly believe that you received exceptional service in a way that wasn’t already priced into the experience; I expect I’d be tipping maybe once or twice a month in practice.